The infection alert is from the file system shield, not from the webshield. According to the path, it looks like it is a file from
Safari's web content cache. What is kind of weard is, that the web shield does not trigger any alert...
Can you post here the "infected" file (/Users/stephenfoster1/Library/Caches/com.apple.Safari/WebkitCache/Version9/Records/No partision/Resource/81276CF1D35B4895614E87VF087287CBBB7E197A
), so we can analyze it? Maybe it is a falsepositive, but without the file, we can't say anything about it.