Hi,
WRT my previous Antivirus package. I have been using Avast since about 2010. I have never used another one as it's always protected me.
I uninstalled previous versions via the add/remove Windows functionality, which opens the Avast Modify/Repair/Uninstall screen. BTW, I have tried each of those options already.
Based on your suggestion, I re-installed again and made the firewall Private setting as you mentioned. Same as other attempts. Everything seems to work but when I reboot it all goes pear-shaped. I turned off the Avast Firewall altogether (just to see) but still the same issue.
I've uninstalled again, needing to use Safe Mode.
Another bit of info, when it's in its 'nothing working' state, Windows Search also doesn't work and when I look in Settings, most screens are empty/blank.
Am I safe with Windows Defender?