Hi Resourceful
I'm no expert, but I would recommend you try scanning in safe mode. If you hold down F8 while starting up your computer, it will boot in safe mode. Then you can run a new scan with Avast and Malwarebytes. In addition, I noted you only did a quick scan. This is not enough, you need to do a full scan.
This way Avast found a trojan on my sister's computer that screwed it up so bad it would barely boot.
If you still find nothing, I would recommend downloading the Microsoft Malicious Software Removal Tool (I believe you can get here:
http://www.microsoft.com/security/malwareremove/default.aspx)
Also, you may want to try Super Anti Spyware as well. (
http://superantispyware.com/ )
Also I would say run a Boot Scan with Avast. You might have something hiding in your memory. You can do this by Starting Avast and clicking on the menu button on the upper left, and then I believe the option is there to start a boot scan.
And last but not least, if none of these fix it, download Hijack This (
http://free.antivirus.com/hijackthis/).
This will not fix the problem but will provide an extensive log of your files so hopefully someone more computer literate can determine the cause.
Good luck!